A Emotional Intelligence Inventory (MEII) by Dr.

A COMPARATIVE STUDY OF EMOTIONAL
INTELLIGENCE AMONG INDIVIDUAL AND TEAM-BASED SPORTS ATHLETES Ruby Pawar, Head, Department of
Psychology, K. R. T. Arts, A. M. Commerce & B. H. Science College,
Nashik. Savitribai Phule Pune University, Pune.
 Abstract The purpose of present
research is to compare the emotional
intelligence of team-based and individual sport athletes. In order to
evaluate emotional intelligence, Mangal Emotional Intelligence Inventory
(MEII) by Dr. S. K. Mangal and Mrs. Shubhra Mangal was used which measures Inter-Personal Awareness, Intra-Personal
Awareness, Intra-Personal Management,
Inter-personal Management and Overall Emotional Intelligence.  On
collecting data and using (K-S) test and further making certain that the data
is naturally distributed (P > 0.05), descriptive statistics (mean and
standard deviation) and independent ‘t’ test was used. The results clearly indicated that there is a
significant difference in
Inter-Personal Awareness, Inter- personal Management and Overall Emotional Intelligence among team and individual sport athletes. Keywords:
Emotional intelligence, Individual sports athletes, Team based sports
athletes Introduction Research findings have shown that emotional experiences of athletes and the ability to control
the destructive negative emotions is the major part of preparation of athletes. The results of studies conducted regarding
the effective medalist athletes imply that
among the effective factors impacting the performance of athletes, the
ability to recognize, manage and express the feelings logically in stressful
situations is highly important. On the other hand, according to development
of different methods of exercise and techniques of skill execution, the
quality of exercise sessions, flexibility, speed, high power and physical
preparedness cannot singly guarantee the success of athletes and or teams,
but development and improvement of mental preparedness and paying attention
to factors such as self-confidence, awareness of one’s and others feelings, self-management,
adequate emotional energy and emotion management would lead to transfer of
learnt skills from exercise sessions to competition time in a positive
manner. The results of studies conducted regarding identification of factors
impacting athletes’ performance indicate that experience, skill level,
concentration, presence of spectators, severe excitation, control
center and hostile condition are of the most
important variables impacting the performance of athletes particularly in
sensitive events. But professional athletes apply different types of mental
skills in order to control their competitive anxiety and facilitating high
performance during competitions. Bois E. (2009) in his research indicated
that having excellent physical performance and possessing high level mental
skills is necessary for the success of athletes. He believes that the
athletes, who have different performance levels, would probably have
different mental skills. The results of Pigozzie’s study (2008) indicated
that genius athletes have good motivation and self-confidence through
controlling competitive anxiety by mental skills (such as imaging, emotion
control) but amateur athletes are faced with a significant decrease in their
performance due to high anxiety during competitions. Hanton (2000) believes
that Olympic athletes use mental skills particularly imaging and
self-confidence for displaying an excellent performance, but amateur
athletes, with the aim of reducing competitive anxiety in stressful
conditions, apply mental skill techniques. Hanton and Connaughton (2002)
based on their research on the impact of mental skills on the performance of
swimmers reported that Olympic athletes are aware of positive impacts of
mental skills on performance, so they apply imaging, positive self-talk and
other previously successful methods and techniques in order to achieve
success. Covassin (2004) considers emotional preparedness as a part of mental
preparedness and believes that emotional preparedness has a significant role
in decision making, proper performance, increase of morale and motivation of
athletes and finally team efficacy improvement. Andrew et al (2006) in his
study on investigating the relationship between emotional intelligence and
behavioral features with performance of student athletes, believes that
having balanced behavioral features such as controlling negative emotions
and motivations in a proper level are the
characteristics of superior athletes and states that emotional intelligence
has a positive relationship with optimum performance and self- efficacy of
superior athletes that separates the performance of these athletes from
others in sensitive and important events. Based on a research performed by
Vassiliki (2009) on genius Taekwondo and Judo players, he reported that
emotional intelligence has a direct relationship with excellent physical
image and optimum performance and the athletes who have higher emotional
intelligence, have higher performance by accepting the responsibility and
mistakes of their teammates. Zizzi (2003) while confirming the positive
relationship between emotional intelligence and performance believes that
possessing social skills, undertaking the responsibility and mistakes of
their teammates are of the most important characteristics of genius athletes.
The researches of Gohm et al (2003) indicated that emotional intelligence of
athletes increases self-efficacy and effectiveness by impacting on behavioral properties. Narimani (2009) believes that
emotional intelligence impacts athletes’ performance and this impact in team
sports is higher than that in individual sports and the athletes of the team
that has higher emotional intelligence would achieve higher success compared
to individual athletes. Perlini (2009) investigating the relationship between
the impact of emotional intelligence on hockey players has reported that
emotional intelligence is one of the effective mental skills on performance
and self- efficacy of genius athletes that increases individual and team
efficacy. Meyers (2007) reported that the understanding of team-mates, behavioral properties, self-confidence, concentration and emotional disorders are of the
main factors impacting the performance of athletes. Therefore, in order to
achieve optimum application of sport skills, possessing physical
preparedness, skill preparedness, tactic and mental preparedness are very
necessary. So, based on the importance of the positive impact of emotional
intelligence on success, in present research, the level of emotional intelligence among individual and team sport athletes was
compared. Research methodology The present
research aims to compare emotional
intelligence of individual and team- based sport athletes. The sample
consisted of 70 athletes, 35 of them are team-based sports athletes
(Volleyball, Kabaddi, Football and Basketball) and 35 athletes are of
individual sports (track and field, fencing, shooting, karate and swimming)
from Nashik. Tool used Mangal Emotional Intelligence Inventory (MEII). This questionnaire
measures 4 areas of emotional intelligence namely, Intra-personal Awareness, Inter-personal Awareness, Intra-personal
Management and Inter-Personal Management on a Yes/No scale. The
reliability of this test was examined by split-half method, K-R formula (20)
and test-retest. The reliability coefficient was 0.89, 0.90 and 0.92
respectively. After obtaining scores on the test
and using (K-S) test and making certain of data natural distribution (P >
0.05), descriptive statistics (mean and standard deviation) and independent
‘t’ test was calculated. Research findings 70 athletes from individual
sports (track and field, fencing, shooting, karate and swimming) and
team-based sports such as Volleyball, Kabaddi, Football and Basketball accepted to participate in this research. The
mean scores of Intra-Personal Awareness (19.26), Intra-personal Management (19.23) of individual sport athletes is higher than that of team sport athletes whereas the Inter-Personal Awareness (19.73),
Inter-personal Management (20.63) and Overall Emotional Intelligence (77.69) of team sport athletes is greater than that of individual sport athletes
(table1). Table1: The mean of 4 areas and Overall Emotional Intelligence of individual and team-based sports
athletes Areas of Emotional Intelligence
Individual athletes(n=35) Team athletes (n=35) M Sd M Sd
Intra-personal awareness 19.26 2.88 18.94 2.67
Inter-personal Awareness 16.31 4.24 19.17 3.19 Intra-personal Management 19.23 2.62 18.94 3.65
Inter-personal Management 15.14 2.79 20.63 2.38 Overall Emotional
Intelligence 69.94 6.32 77.69 7.05 The
results of ‘t’ test indicated that there is significant difference between Inter- Personal Awareness (t = 3.19, P < 0.05), Inter-personal Management (t= 8.86, P < 0.05) and Overall Emotional Intelligence (t = 4.84, P < 0.05), between individual and team-based sport athletes; but no significant difference was observed in Intra-personal awareness and Intra-Personal Management (P > 0.05) (table 2). Table 2: A
comparison of 4 areas of Emotional Intelligence
of individual and team-based sports athletes Areas of Emotional
Intelligence Std. Error M. differ ‘t’ Intra-personal awareness 0.66 0.31 0.47 Inter-personal Awareness 0.90 2.86 *3.19 Intra-personal Management 0.76 0.29 0.38
Inter-personal Management 0.62 5.49 *8.86 Overall Emotional Intelligence 1.60
7.74 *4.84 *Significant ‘t’ value Discussion and Conclusion The results of present research demonstrated
that there is significant difference in the Inter-Personal
Awareness, Inter-personal Management and Overall Emotional Intelligence of individual and
team-based sports athletes. The team-based sports athletes scored
higher than individual sport athletes
in these three areas. So, the coaches and
sport experts must apply psychological sport findings and develop the emotional intelligence of individuals on
applied manner in exercise sessions to improve their performance. The
findings showed that though the individual athletes scored higher on
Intra-Personal Awareness and Intra-Personal
Management there was no significant
difference between the individual and team-based sports athletes. Possibly since the success of
individual athletes depends only to their performance, these athletes
possess lower Inter-Personal Awareness,
Inter-personal Management and Overall Emotional Intelligence than team athletes whose success depends to the
performance of all team members. Eric (1996) in his investigation of
self-confidence impact on the performance of team and individual athletes
reported that there is no significant relationship in competitive anxiety
levels and self-confidence between male and female athletes. But when the
athletes were studied based on nature of the sport field (team based and
individual), it was observed that female athletes have more negative thinking
and lower relaxation than their male counterparts that is consistent to the present
research. Calmels (2002) in a similar research stated that the nature of
sport (team based or individual) and the gender of athletes are of effective
factors impacting their performance. He stated that individual athletes
compared to team ones experience higher levels of negative thinking and
self-talk whereas team athletes possessing better communicative skills have
more ability in motivating their team mates. The findings of Zizzi’s research
have indicated that experienced athletes induce their teammates for achieving
the goals determined by coach through making effective communication to their
teammates (social skills), encouraging and enhancing the role of inexperienced
ones at the time of committing individual mistakes (empathy) and accepting
and undertaking the responsibility and mistakes of their teammates
(self-awareness and self-motivation). In this research, a significant
relationship was observed between emotional intelligence and athletes’
experience. Meyers (2007) stated that paying attention to emotional
experiences of athletes and the ability of controlling it is a main part of
preparation plan of Olympic and genius athletes and continued that understanding
the teammates, anxiety, behavioral properties and emotional disorders are of
the most important factors impacting athletes’ performance. Gohm (2003)
believes that only 30% of athletes are aware of the impact of emotional
intelligence on performance and apply it and team athletes use more social
skills, empathy and self-motivation than individual athletes. The
psychologists and coaches of teams must incorporate emotional preparation
strategies in order to modify and control negative feelings and enhance
positive emotional modes in their coaching. References Andrew M. Lane, Richard Thelwell (2006).
Emotional Intelligence and Mood States associated with Optimal Performance.
Electronic Journal of Applied Psychology: General Articles. 5(1): 67-73.
Bois.E.(2009). Psychological characteristics and their relation to
performance. The sport psychologist.23, 252-270. Calmels.C(2002). DEVELOPMENT
OF MENTAL SKILLS AMONG ATHLETES. Expert use in Elite Sport – INSEP, 12 – 15.
Covassin, T., Pero, S., 2004, The relationship between self-confidence, anxiety
and mood state, and anxiety among collegiate tennis players, Journal of Sport
Behavior, (1), 55-70. Eric, T, Kring. J(1996).Anxiety and self-confidance in
relation to individual and team sport. Psi Journal of Undergraduate
Research.V 1,N1-2:33- 35. Hanton, S, Connaughton, D. (2002) Perceived control
of anxiety and its relationship to self- confidence and performance. Research
Quarterly for Exercise and Sport 73, 87-97. Hanton, S., Jones, G. and Mullen,
R. (2000) Intensity and direction of competitive anxiety as interpreted by
rugby players and rifle shooters. Perceptual and motor skills. 90,513-521.
Gohm, C. L. (2003). Mood Regulation and Emotional Intelligence: Individual
Differences. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 84, 594-607. Meyer
BB, Zizzi S (2007). Emotional intelligence in sport: conceptual,
methodological, and applied issues. In: Lane AM (Ed.), Mood and Human
Performance: Conceptual, Measurement, and Applied Issues. pp. 131–54.
Narimani,M, Bashar poor.S(2009).Comparison of attachment style and emotional
intelligence between women and non-athletes women. Research journal of biological science.4(2):216- 221.
Perlini,H, Halverson,R.T(2006).Emotional intelligence in the national hockey
team. Journal of beah.sci.38(2):109-119. Pigozzi, A Spataro, A Alabiso, A
Parisi, M Rizzo (2004). Role of exercise stress test in master athletes. Br J
Sports Med .39:527–531. doi: 10.1136/bjsm.2004.014340. Vassiliki.D,Dimitra.S(2009).Emotional entilligence, Body
image and disorder eating in combat sport athletes .journal of sport
science.7(2):104- 111. Zizzi, S. J., Deaner, H. R., & Hirschhorn, D. K.
(2003). The relationship between emotional intelligence and performance among
college baseball players. Journal of Applied Sport Psychology, 15, 262-269.