Should Poland adopt the Euro? Sample Essay

The euro is like an old Catholic nuptials: like it or non. happy or non. you are married everlastingly. But fortuitously. you know the bride in progress. You know what it takes and what it needs to populate with her and do certain your brotherhood is a happy one“ . said Mr. Joaquin Almunia. EU pecuniary personal businesss commissioner. at the Vilnius conference in October 2006. Although Poland has one of the strongest economic systems in the EU – the country’s cardinal bank predicts growing of 3. 2 per cent in 2012. faster than merely about everyplace else in the EU. its long term end should be to fall in the common currency. The European Union is faced with turning uncertainties over the ability of the political procedure to accomplish a necessary consensus sing medium-term financial accommodation. which is critically of import for planetary stableness. As political leaders in these advanced economic systems have non yet commanded wide political support for sufficiently beef uping macro-financial stableness and for implementing growth-enhancing reforms. markets have begun to oppugn their ability to take much needed action.

As an Emerging market Poland must restrict the buildup of fiscal instabilities while puting the foundations of a more robust fiscal model. Eurozone officeholders know really good that if states embrace the common currency excessively early they are a possible beginning of instability. Poland is frequently compared to a little boat on a big ocean. In the event of a big storm. speedy manoeuvres thanks to a floating exchange rate will intend small. In contrast to the UK. Poland is non proud of non being a member of the Eurozone. The success of the euro undertaking and the strengthening of economic administration in the common currency lies in Poland’s historical involvement. In the terminal. Poland wants to swiftly fall in a reinforced Eurozone so as non to be left entirely on the ocean.

Although Poland’s economic system is well smaller than those of EU human dynamo. Germany and France. what it lacks in size. it makes up in growing. This twelvemonth Warsaw expects to see end product spread out by 3. 8 per centum compared to the 1. 6 percent norm for the largely richer 17-member Eurozone. harmonizing to International Monetary Fund ( IMF ) estimates. The largest of 10 ex-communist provinces to hold joined the EU. 38-million strong Poland distinguished itself by hiting 1. 7 per centum end product growing in 2009. and so go the lone member of the 27-state axis to avoid skiding into recession amid the planetary crisis. Although Poland does non hold the euro. its economic hereafter is closely tied to the success of the common currency. Sixty per cent of Polish exports go to the Eurozone. Let us research how the relationship between Poland and the Eurozone is on the Economic. political. legal and societal degrees.

We Will Write a Custom Essay Specifically
For You For Only $13.90/page!

order now


Economists have approached the inquiry of currency fusion mostly through the lens of economic costs and benefits. The benefits are intuitive: if there is significant trade and investing activity across an country. a individual currency should ease economic interactions by extinguishing the dealing costs of making concern in many currencies and extinguishing the hazards associated with fluctuating currencies

So. What are Potential costs of fall ining the euro zone?
The hazard of a procyclical influence of the EBC pecuniary policy

The possible costs of fall ining the euro zone are related chiefly to the hazard that the ECB pecuniary policy may exercise a pro-cyclical influence on the economic systems of the EMU member states. If concern rhythms within a pecuniary brotherhood are non sufficiently synchronized. the differences in expected rates of rising prices may bring forth differences in the existent degree of involvement rates. This may. in bend. bring forth a pro-cyclical influence of the common pecuniary policy on the economic systems of the pecuniary brotherhood.

The ECB pecuniary policy turned out to be pro-cyclical in some member states. The inordinate enlargement produced a big addition in ULC ( unit labor costs ) . the REER ( Real Effective Exchange Rate ) grasp. and the undermentioned economic lag. The existent job is the hazard that the period of recovering fight by a given state may be long. because a devaluation in non a feasible option. The procedure of recovering fight is long when the rate of growing in productiveness is low. The other factor. which makes the adjustment procedure long. is the low downward snap of rewards. Under these fortunes. the procedure of recovering fight needs a long period of comparatively low economic growing. which might convey about a sufficient lessening in unit labor costs.

Will the ECB pecuniary policy be pro-cyclical in the instance of Poland? Poland enjoys a high rate of productiveness growing which would shorten the period of retrieving productiveness after a period of REER grasp. The other of import factor is that the disinflation of the Polish economic system is completed. The CPI and the involvement rate degree are really similar as in the euro zone. Poland’s entry into the euro zone would non convey approximately such a big autumn in involvement rate degree. as was the instance in Portugal. Greece. Spain and Italy.

The hazard of asymmetric dazes

The possible costs of come ining a euro zone pecuniary brotherhood root besides from the fact that Poland might non be able to utilize pecuniary policy in order to neutralize the impact of asymmetric dazes. The hazard is non conjectural. The Italian economic system experienced an inauspicious asymmetric daze ensuing from the growing in Asiatic exports to Europe. The strength of this daze was enlarged by the grasp of the euro against the dollar. The effects for the Italian economic system were so painful that Italian politicians started to speak about a backdown from the euro zone. The costs of such backdown would be so high that such an option is non feasible.

Is Italy’s experience relevant for Poland? It is. but to a limited extent. Poland economic system went through the daze produced by imports from China and other Asiatic states and this was during a period of rather significant zloty existent grasp. One has to take into consideration besides the fact that the most likely factor bring forthing inauspicious asymmetric dazes are big motions of the exchange Despite the Polish zloty moderateness. there is ever a hazard of an addition in exchange rate volatility. which might trip a tendency forcing the zloty far off from its equilibrium degree. The hazard that other factors might bring forth asymmetric dazes will be shriveling with Poland’s turning economic integrating with the euro zone.

What are the costs of being outside the euro zone?

The hazard of exchange rate motions disconnected from basicss

High productiveness growing in the accession states enables them to better the fight of their economic systems. However. for those holding fixed exchange rates. such as the Baltic provinces. this is a assorted approval bring forthing a struggle between nominal and existent convergence. A high rate of productiveness growing. like in Poland. enables the corporate sector to raise rewards without raising export monetary values. However. the growing in rewards spills over the whole labor market which pushes up rewards in the services sector. where the rate of productiveness is comparatively low. This brings about a higher rate of rising prices. In 2005-2007. the Polish zloty did appreciate approximately in conformity with the estimations of its equilibrium rate. The growing in productiveness enabled rewards to turn. but the grasp of the zloty helped to maintain rising prices in cheque. The chief job with a floating exchange rate is that there is ever a hazard that it might divert for a long period of clip from its equilibrium degree. The hazard can non be neutralized by cardinal bank intercessions in the foreign exchange market. There are state of affairss when step ining in the foreign exchange market might be effectual. However. normally intercessions are expensive and convey approximately ephemeral consequences. Therefore. the of import cost of being outside the euro zone is the hazard that the motions of the zloty might go from its equilibrium rate.

The decreasing range for pecuniary policy liberty

The turning mobility of international capital flows reduces the range for independent pecuniary policy even in states holding drifting exchange rates. Cardinal Bankss in emerging economic systems normally take into consideration the impact of their involvement policy on the motions of exchange rates. They merely seek non to arouse exchange rate volatility which might hold an inauspicious impact on the existent economic system. The hazard of triping such motions of exchange rates increases with the turning graduated table of the planetary carry trade. This has reverberations for exchange rate policy. In the 1970s and the 1980s. devaluation might be an effectual tool to recover fight of a given economic system when it was combined with sufficient tightening in pecuniary and financial policy. However. at that clip the mobility of capital flows was much smaller. Nowadays. under the much increased mobility of international capital flows. a big figure of states have drifting exchange rates. Due to the rise in the mobility of international capital flows. much larger current histories are easy financed without ensuing in a significant addition in the state ( default ) hazard. Quite frequently. even big current history shortages do non automatically bring forth currencies depreciations. Conversely. one time the impairment on the current history is caused by increased rising prices. a rise in involvement rates frequently brings about an exchange rate grasp.


Under the footings of the Treaty of Accession 2003. all new Member States “shall take part in the Economic and Monetary Union from the day of the month of Accession as a Member State with a derogation” . which means that Poland is obliged to present the euro. which will replace its current currency. the Zloty. Article 227 [ 1 ] of the Constitution of the Republic of Poland will necessitate to be amended to let a alteration of currency from the Zloty to the euro and a alteration of the cardinal bank. so Poland may follow the Euro no earlier than 2019. This move excessively would necessitate the support of at least several lawgivers of the chief resistance party. the conservative-nationalist and euro- skeptic Law and Justice.


In June 2010. wide understanding was eventually reached on a controversial proposal for member provinces to peer reexamine each others budgets prior to their presentation to national parliaments. If a state was to run a shortage. they would hold to warrant it to the remainder of the EU while states with a debt more than 60 % of GDP would confront greater examination. In March 2011 was initiated a new reform of the Stability and Growth Pact taking at unbending the regulations by following an automatic process for imposing of punishments in instance of breaches of either the shortage or the debt regulations The effects of what President Nicolas Sarkozy and Chancellor Angela Merkel are make up one’s minding among themselves may hold a profound impact on Poland if it finally joins the EU’s currency axis. The Gallic and German leaders proposed that euro-zone members lose entree to help financess if they run what the EU calls “excessive budget shortages. ” above 3 % of economic end product.

The Polish authorities has insisted repeatedly against a two-speed Europe in which it would be left outside the EU nucleus. For that ground it pledged to fall in the “euro plus” treaty. in which the euro zone and several non-euro EU members set ends functioning longer-term fiscal stableness. Poland is one of the largest donees of EU funds–a major driver of the country’s current economic growing. Poland besides ran a really high general authorities shortage of 7. 9 % of end product last twelvemonth and will fight to cut it below the EU’s 3 % bound in 2012. If Poland joins the euro zone and the proposed regulation is enacted. it could lose one million millions of euros a twelvemonth in the financess if its shortage slips out of control of all time once more. One of the EU’s poorer members. Poland would therefore put on the line going a net subscriber of financess to the axis.

The proposal to aline corporate revenue enhancement governments of Germany and France. if extended to other euro-zone members. could potentially deter foreign investing in Poland. The corporate income revenue enhancement rate in the state is at 19 % . compared to the rates around 30 % in both Germany and France.

An institutionalised council regulating the euro zone would intend Poland would be for good outside the decision-making procedure. The euro country could in the interim germinate further. going even less of what Poland foremost signed up for. INTERNAL SOCIAL ISSUES

The planetary fiscal crisis that began in 2008 derailed Poland’s original thrust to follow the euro in 2012. Public sentiment research by CBOS from March 2011 shows that 60 % of Poles are against altering the PLN. Merely 32 % of Poles want it. compared to 41 % in April 2010 Poland’s pro-European authorities. led by the centre-right Civic Platform ( PO ) party which won four more old ages in power in an Oct. 9 election. does non hold a specific mark day of the month for euro rank. Poland is one of the new EU member provinces. It joined together with 9 former Soviet orbiters in 2004 but since the autumn of the Berlin wall the state went along a long and successful manner of full transmutation and turned its dorsum to the yesteryear. while pulling the right lessons. Now is non the right clip the state to lose all this. is the Poles’ feeling. who resisted to fall in the eurozone because they feared that the rigorous standards ( most of all rising prices and shortage ) would halter the so needful growing for economic convergence. Decision

As the market heebie-jeebiess during the current economic crisis have demonstrated. replacing the euro with the zloty may non be basically the best thought at this point. Poland’s free-floating national currency. when it weakened aggressively in the first moving ridge of the crisis after the prostration of Lehman Brothers. cushioned the country’s manufacturers from the autumn of demand outside the state. doing their merchandises more competitively priced to the outside universe and imported goods more expensive. The crisp depreciation of Poland’s free-floating currency. the zloty. helped it absorb the daze by buoying exports. In 2009. it was the lone province in the 27-member EU to get away recession. In the event of even a mild recession in the Eurozone. Poland should still be able to eke out positive economic growing thanks to take down volatility in private ingestion than in affluent states. and to go on profitable exports because of a weaker currency. Demand for Polish exchequers has been turning as they have looked progressively attractive when compared to bonds from Spain or Italy. Poland should concentrate on its strengths-

• A big domestic market. which lowers the economy’s dependance on exports and enables Polish companies to prosecute local gross revenues amid drooping demand in foreign markets
• A diversified economic base

• Strong human capital pulling on a ample cohort of immature professionals
• A figure of economically important regional bunchs ( Bydgoszcz. Gdansk. Katowice. Krakow. Lodz . Poznan . Rzeszow. Szczecin. and Wroclaw in add-on to Warsaw )

And besides lay a model for a more robust fiscal construction. In peculiar: • Coherent policy solutions are needed to cut down autonomous hazards in advanced economic systems and prevent contagious disease. The euro country acme of July 21 and subsequent proclamations by the European Central Bank are significant stairss to heighten the crisis direction model of the euro country. However. it is overriding to guarantee fleet execution of the in agreement stairss and to see farther sweetenings in the economic and fiscal administration model of the euro country. * Emerging market policymakers need to guard against overheating and a buildup of fiscal instabilities through equal macroeconomic and fiscal policies

* Credible attempts are required to beef up the resiliency of the fiscal system and guard against surpluss. Appropriate financial action. combined with steps to beef up Bankss through balance sheet fix and equal capital buffers. can assist interrupt the nexus between crowned head hazard and Bankss.

* The fiscal reform docket needs to be completed every bit shortly as possible and implemented internationally in a consistent mode. This includes the finalisation of Basel III. the intervention of systemically of import fiscal establishments. and turn toing the challenges posed by the shadow banking sector.

Poland must utilize its’ assets to beef up its economic system. while waiting for the right clip to fall in a Eurozone that will be reciprocally good to both parties involved.

Reports AND Articles

1 ) Adopting the Euro: Dilemmas and Tradeoffs Facing EU Accession Countries-James W. Dean Simon Fraser University
2 ) The domestic jobs of following the Euro in Czech Republic. Hungary and
Poland Assem Dandashly* and Amy Verdun**
3 ) Poland: still experiencing the love for the Eurozone
4 ) Emerging Europe and Eurozonitis
Nicholas Watson of concern new Europe
5 ) Poland booming as Eurozone wobbles
Dean Carroll
1 ) International Monetary Fund IMF
2 ) World Trade Organisation WTO
3 ) Bank for International Colonies
4 ) IHS Global Insight
5 ) State Administration of Foreign Exchange SAFE