This paper discusses CUSUM CPA attack for observing alterations in mean of a procedure utilizing malaria clip series informations. The analysis usage s CUSUM and bootstrapping so to turn up the alteration point and do illations severally.
The alteration points detected corresponds to specific events in the period between 2010 and 2011. For the impact sensing there were more alteration points detected after June 2011 than earlier May 2010. There is a strong organic structure of cognition sing the intercessions which were put in between May 2010 and June 2011 which we might hold anticipated to reflect the detected alteration points with decrease in the tendencies of figure of malaria instances. Further research should be done to determine the claim of the alterations detected to govern out if the alterations may hold been due to altering climatic conditions, co-interventions effects or good medical patterns.
We compared our consequences with those from the standard epidemic sensing techniques and found that our method detected some of the alteration points which were detected by the EDS. However, there were those points which were detected by our method merely. This shows that the method could observe elusive alterations which could non be detected by the EDS. The same consequences shows that the points detected coincided with the clip when there were epidemics. For epidemic sensing, malaria EDS detected 34 points, control charts 4 points, CUSUM charts 28 points and CUSUM CPA 3 alteration points.
Our CPA consequences are similar to those of CUSUM CPA sensing method which was used by ( Kass-Hout et al. 2012 ) to observe alterations in exigency admittance tendencies due to influenza unwellness in USA. The assurance degrees, the magnitude and the location of alteration points were given. It besides detected elusive alterations during that period. There is a graphical representation of the location of alteration points merely as alteration point sensing techniques used by ( Killick et al. , 2011, Barry and Hartigan, 1993 ; Bai and Perron, 2003 )
Merely as other alteration point sensing techniques which uses the likelihood-ratio trial ( Killick et al, 2011 ) and Bayesian ( Barry and Hartigan, 1993 ) , our method starts with individual alteration point sensing. If alteration point is detected, so the information set is split into two sections and the process for observing the alteration point is repeated recursively till no alteration point is detected
The method is utilizing the non-parametric attack ( CUSUM calculator ) to turn up the alteration point. These method seems effectual since its utilizing the divergences from the mean across the whole series. In add-on, there is a threshold for make up one’s minding when a threshold has been detected. A minimal assurance degree of is required for the alteration point to be important. And it ‘s besides the guiding factor for the figure of sections to be splitted in a given series. The likeliness ratio trial statistics is normally compared with a threshold to prove for the hypothesis of the alteration point.
Since alteration point sensing is the job of detecting where the clip series informations is sing a displacement, it can be used efficaciously to observe point of alteration due to intercession impacts and epidemics. The lone methods used are the EDS and Malaria Indicator Survey to observe epidemics and assess impacts severally.
One unfavorable judgment of this attack is that it does non observe stray unnatural points. To turn to this concern change-point analysis should be supplemented with a Shewhart control chart when such points are of concern. Another drawback of the CUSUM CPA is that the bootstrapping attack will non bring forth indistinguishable consequences every clip it is performed because of the random choice of the bootstrap samples. This defect can be addressed by increasing the figure of bootstraps so as to progressively hold more precise consequences. A minimal figure of 1000 bootstraps are normally recommended.
We have shown how recent methodological progresss in observing alteration point in mean of a procedure can be applied to some informations sets. The method allows for visual image and graphical analysis which convey information about the presence and the location of alteration points in the information. In add-on there is a significance trial for doing illation for the alteration point detected utilizing bootstrapping which in bend helps to cipher the assurance degree.
The algorithm is non parametric since it does non presume any distribution merely like any other non parametric algorithms.
CUSUM CPA is an effectual tool for observing alterations in mean for clip series informations and should be adopted so as to observe points of alteration due to epidemics or intercession impact together with the bing methods so as to acquire meaningful consequences.
For farther research one should seek alter point analysis utilizing structural alteration theoretical accounts, binary cleavage processs or Bayesian alteration point analysis with application to malaria instances as an eruption or impact sensing method. Detecting alteration points in discrepancy should besides be done.
5.4 Restrictions of the survey
In this survey informations from one instance country was used to observe alterations mean of malaria instances due to epidemics and due to impacts of intercessions. However, the research could hold been more representative if a somewhat larger sample and informations set for longer clip frame was used to give the consequences more cogency.
Because these consequences merely show short-run tendencies in the malaria instances associated with the debut of these control schemes, they need verification in longer surveies.
Amin, R.W. , Reynolds M.R. and Bakir S. ( 1995 ) , ‘Nonparametric quality control charts based on
the mark statistics ‘ , Comm. Stat. Theory Methods 24, 1597-1623.
Bai J, Perron P ( 2003 ) . Calculation and Analysis of Multiple Structural Change Models. ”
Journal of Applied Econometrics, 18, 1-22.
Barker, N. ( 2010 ) , ‘A practical debut to the bootstrap utilizing the SAS system ‘ .
hypertext transfer protocol: //www.lexjansen.com/phuse/2005/pk/pk02.pdf
Barry D, Hartigan JA ( 1993 ) . “ A Bayesian Analysis for Change Point Problems. ” Journal of the
American Statistical Association, 35 ( 3 ) , 309-319.
Basseville, M. and Nikiforov, I.V. ( 1993 ) . Detection of disconnected alterations: theory and application.
Infor-mation and system scientific discipline series. Prentice Hall, Englewood Cliffs, NJ.
Box, G.E.P, Jenkins G.M. and Reinsel G.C. ( 1994 ) , Time series analysis: Prediction and
Control, Prentice Hall, Englewood Cliffs, NJ.
CDC ( 1986 ) , Comprehensive program for epidemic surveillance. Atlanta, Center for Disease
Chen, J. and Gupta A.K. ( 2000 ) , Parametric Statistical Change Point Analysis, Boston,
Cullen, J.R. , Chitprarop U. , Doberstyn E.B and Sombatwattanangkul K. ( 1984 ) , ‘An
epidemiological early warning system for malaria control in northern Thailand ‘ , Bull
World Health Organ 62, 107-114.
De Vries, A. , and Reneau J.K ( 2010 ) , Application of statistical procedure control charts to supervise
alterations in carnal production systems. J. Animal Sci, 10, 2009-2622
Downey, A.B ( 2008 ) . A fresh changepoint sensing algorithm. Application Statistics, 1-11
Efron, B. and Tibshirani R. ( 1993 ) , An Introduction to the Bootstrap, Chapman & A ; Hall.
Efron, B. ( 1987 ) “ Better Bootstrap Confidence Intervals ” , Journal of the American Statistical
Association, 92, 171-185
Efron, B. ( 1982 ) “ The Jackknife, the Bootstrap and Other Resampling Plans ” , Society for
Industrial and Applied Mathematics, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania
Erdman C, Emerson JW ( 2007 ) . bcp: A Package for Performing a Bayesian Analysis of Change
Point Problems. Journal of Statistical Software, 23, 1-13
Gavit, P. , Baddour Y. and Tholmer R. ( 2009 ) , ‘Use of change-point analysis for procedure
monitoring and control ‘ , BioPharm International 22, 1-13.
Hawkynss, D.M. , Qui P. and King C.W. ( 2003 ) , ‘The alteration point theoretical account for statistical procedure
control ‘ , Journal of Quality Tecnology 35, 355-366.
Hawkynss, D M and Zamba, K D. ( 2005 ) Statistical Process Control for Shifts in Mean or
Variance utilizing a Change Point Formulation. Technometrics 47, 164-173
Hay, S.I. , Simba M. , Busolo M. , Noor A.M. , Guyatt H.L. , Ochola S.A. and Snow R.W. ( 2002 ) ,
‘Defining and observing malaria epidemics in the Highlandss of western kenya ‘ ,
Emerg. Infect Dis 8, 555-562.
Hensen B ( 2001 ) . The new econometrics of structural alteration: dating alterations in U.S. labour
productiveness. J Econ Perspect ; 15:117e28.
Hinkley, D. and Schechtman E. ( 1987 ) , ‘Conditional bootstrap methods in the mean-shift
theoretical account ‘ , Biometrika 74, 85-93.
Hinkley, D.V. ( 1971 ) , ‘Inference about the change-point from cumulative amount trials ‘ , Biometrika
Kass-Hout, T.A. , Xu Z. , McMurray P. , Park S. , Buckeridge D.L. Brownstein J.S. , Finelli L. and
Groseclose S.L. ( 2012 ) , ‘Application of alteration point analysis to daily to daily influenza-
like-illness ( ili ) exigency section visits ‘ , Journal of American Medical Information sciences
Association ; pp. 1-16.
Killick, R. , Eckley, I.A. , Ewans, K. , Jonathan, P. ( 2010 ) Detection of alterations in discrepancy of
oceanographic time-series utilizing changepoint analysis. Ocean Engineering 37, 1120-1126
McKelvie, W.R. , Haghdoost A.A. and Raeisi A. ( 2012 ) , ‘Defining and observing malaria
epidemics in south-east Iran ‘ , Malaria diary 11, 1-16.
Montgomery, D.C. ( 2000 ) , Introduction to Statistical Quality Control, 4th edn, New York: John
Wiley & A ; Sons.
Okiro, E.A. , Hay S.I. , Gikandi P.W. , Sharif S.K. , Noor A.M. , Peshu N. , Marsh K. and Snow
R.W. ( 2007 ) , ‘The diminution in pediatric malaria admittances on the seashore of Kenya ‘ ,
Malaria diary 6, 1-16.
Olshen AB, Venkatraman ES ( 2004 ) . Round Binary Segmentation for the Analysis of Array
based DNA Copy Number Data. Biostatistics, 5 ( 4 ) , 557-572.
Page, E.S. ( 1954 ) , ‘Continuous review strategies ‘ , Biometrika 41, 100-115.
Roll Back Malaria ( RBM ) ( 2001 ) : Malaria early warning systems: a model for field research
in Africa: constructs, indexs and spouses Geneva: RBM ;
Sallis, P. , Claster, W. , and Hernandez, S. ( 2011 ) An algorithm for preciting air current gust events.
Computers and the Geosciences, Elsevier [ in print for 2011 ]
Sastri, T. , Flores B. and Valdes J. ( 1989 ) , ‘Detecting points of alteration in clip series ‘ , Computers
Open Research 16, 271-293.
Sanghvi P ( 2008 ) . Detection of exchanging clip. MS Thesis, Texas Tech University
Taylor, W. ( 2000b ) , ‘A pattern trial for separating between autoregressive and meanshift
informations ‘ , Submitted to Journal of Quality Technologies.
Taylor, W.A. ( 2010 ) , ‘Change-point analysis: A powerful new tool for observing alterations ‘ . Uniform resource locators:
hypertext transfer protocol: //www.variation.com/anonftp/pub/changepoint.pdf ( Accessed 30.04.2012 )
Teklehaimanot HD, Schwatrz J, Teklehaimanot A, Lipsitch M ( 2004 ) : Alert threshold algorithms
and malaria epidemic sensing. Emerg Infect Dis, 10:1220-1226.
Wagner, A.K. , Soumerai, S.B, Zhang, F. and Ross-Degnan, D. ( 2002 ) . Segmented arrested development
analysis of interrupted clip series surveies in medicine usage research. Journal of Clinical
and Therapeutics 27, 299-309
Wangdi, K. , Kaewkungwal J. , Singhasiranon P. , Silawan T. , Lawpoolsri S and White N.J.
( 2011 ) , ‘Spatio-temporal forms of malaria infection in Bhutan: a state shiping on
malaria riddance ‘ , Malaria diary 10, 1-16.
Wetherill, G.B. and Brown D.W. ( 1991 ) , Statistical Process Control, New York: Chapman & A ; Hall.
WHO ( 2001 ) , Malaria early gaining system, a model for field research in Africa: constructs,
indexs and spouses WHO/CDS/RBM/2001.32. , Geneva: The Organisation.
Yao YC ( 1984 ) . Appraisal of a Noisy Discrete-time Step Function: Bayes and Empirical Bayes Approaches. The Annals of Statistics, 12 ( 4 ) , 1434-1447.
Yao, Y. , ( 1988 ) . Estimating the figure of change-points via Schwarz ‘ standard. Statisticss and
Probability Letters 6, 181-189.
Yigiter, A. ( 2012 ) . Change Point Analysis in Earthquake Data, Earthquake Research and
Analysis – Statistical Surveies, Observations and Planning, InTech, Available from:
hypertext transfer protocol: //www.intechopen.com/books/earthquake-research-and-analysis-statistical-studies-
observations-and-planning/change-point-analysis-in-earthquake-data, 1-16 ( Accessed